Everyone loves pie at a picnic. Call today or stop on by to place your order for your Memorial Day pie. We're taking orders until the end of day Thursday.

New menu, the new Very Berry Spodee Pie and new hours! We have changed our menu over for the spring - Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb, Berry Lavender Crumb, Lime Basil, Banana Cream, Chocolate Cherry Meringue and the Very Berry Spodee Pie! Also, starting this Friday our we will be open late - till 11PM on Friday and Saturday and now opening at noon on Sunday till 7PM.

Starting May 1st - The Very Berry Spodee Pie! Made with Spodee - wine with a kick, the Very Berry Pie will be offered for the entire month of May. Try a slice or as a Pie Milkshake with an added shot of Spodee. Also, on Saturdays from 8 - 10, enjoy a nightcap - a slice of the Very Berry Pie and a complimentary glass of Spodee!

Enjoy your favorite slice of pie as a milkshake. We blend a whole slice of pie into Bassett's vanilla ice cream. You can use a straw, but we recommend a spoon to finish it off.

It's getting warm outside...perfect time for new cooler things on our menu. Magpie is now offering Pie Milkshakes featuring your favorite slice of sweet pie. Choose any slice from our menu and we'll add delicious Bassetts Vanilla Ice Cream and blend it to perfectly creamy and chunky goodness. Fruit Milkshakes $8.50, Cream/Custard Milkshakes $8.00.

New addition to the savory section of our menu. Spaghetti Herb pie with ricotta and mozzarella cheese served on a spicy marinara sauce.

Magpie will be closed on Sunday, March 31st and reopn on Tuesday, April 2nd. Have a great holiday!

This Weekend! 

The cherry blossoms are starting to peak out on South Street. 
Celebrate the first sign of spring with Magpie!

Sour Cherry with Rosemary Crumb
Cherry Jubilee Cream
Chocolate Fudge with Black Cherry

The Mini Trio for $10 or individually for $4 each. 

We’re now taking orders for Easter pies! Our flavors are:

Buttery Caramel Apple Pie
Coconut Cream 
Lemon Curd

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Butterscotch Bourbon

Come on by or call us (267-519-2904) to place an order during open hours.
We will be excepting orders up to Thursday, March 28th at 5:00 pm.
Pick-up will on Saturday, March 30th between 11:00 am to 10:00 pm.

Guinness Chocolate Cream topped a with Pretzel Crunch

Irish Coffee Mousse with Whipped Cream

Creme de Menthe with Chocolate Shavings

All three for $10 or individual for $4 each.

This weekend only we are featuring our Reuben Pie along with a special Irish Mini Trio!

Layers of Hot Corned beef, Swiss cheese, with Russian dressing, and sauerkraut, topped with a buttery crust and caraway seeds. Served with side of home made pickled vegetables for $8.50. We also have our Shepherd's Pot Pie with Cauliflower Mash for $9.50.

Our Mini Trio this weekend has the luck of the Irish...

Guinness Chocolate Cream topped a with Pretzel Crunch
Irish Coffee Mousse with Whipped Cream
Creme de Menthe with Chocolate Shavings

All three for $10 or individually for $4 each.